Tyler Green
Art-focused Journalism by Tyler Green

Tyler Green Modern Art Notes

After MAN post, Clough emails Smithsonian staff

Pin It

After MAN’s afternoon scoop (or see the post below this one) and just before 6pm, Smithsonian Secretary G. Wayne Clough sent out this email to Smithsonian staff and to at least a few art museum directors. Note that it fails to express support for the exhibition.

Subject: Message From the Secretary

Dear Colleagues:

I am writing to address the coverage and comments in the news media and online surrounding NPG’s exhibition, “Hide/Seek: Difference and Desire in American Portraiture” which explores the role of gender identity in American portraiture. I toured it early on with curator David Ward and was impressed by the depth of the scholarship and thoughtfulness of the exhibition.

Most of the recent attention about the exhibition has focused on 11 seconds of a four-minute video clip, perceived by some to be anti-Christian and intentionally provocative. Neither description could be further from the truth. However, it was clear that this video was detracting from the entirety of the exhibition, so NPG removed the video.

That decision was not made lightly or in a vacuum. After consulting with NPG Director Marty Sullivan and others at the museum, and Richard Kurin, Under Secretary for History, Art and Culture, I made the final decision to take down the video.

I understand this move is being criticized by some, and I accept that and understand their frustrations. Our mission is the increase and diffusion of knowledge, and sometimes that sparks controversy and prompts uncomfortable debate. This is clearly one of those times.

I am proud to be the Secretary of this Institution, and I am inspired by the work each of you contributes to our success.

Wayne Clough

Pin It


  1. Eric says:

    Subject: Message From David Wojnarowicz

    I am shouting my invisible words. I am getting so weary. I am growing tired. I am waving at you from here. I am crawling and looking for the aperture of complete and final emptiness. I am vibrating in isolation among you. I am screaming but it comes out like pieces of clear ice. I am signaling that the volume of all this is too high. I am waving. I am waving my hands. I am disappearing. I am disappearing but not fast enough.

  2. Bennett says:

    Clough does not name Wojnarowicz even once in his statement.

  3. Candy Darling says:

    What Miss Thing fails to recognize is he f*cked with the wrong artist on the wrong day. This was a deliberate attempt by bigots to get back at David on World AIDS Day. Make no fucking mistake about that.

    & @ Eric: Bravo! (because that is exactly what is going on here).

  4. […] repeated in the story itself. Remarkably, the NYT story never mentions Clough.) As Clough admitted in an email to Smithsonian staff late yesterday, he pulled the video, not the […]

  5. […] that the Association of Art Museum Directors might have complained that the Smithsonian Secretary G. Wayne Clough forced a museum director into an act of censorship? You’d be […]

  6. […] Four hours after MAN broke this story, Clough publicly took responsibility for yanking the Wojnarowicz. After MAN post, Clough emails Smithsonian staff » « […]

  7. […] G. Wayne Clough [above]. That news broke at 3:30 in the afternoon. A few hours later Clough sent an email to Smithsonian staff confirming that story and taking personal responsibility for censoring […]

Add a Comment